Rate Brief ENDE

ECB paper: the EU-US securitisation gap is smaller once covered bonds count

The European Central Bank published Occasional Paper No 403 on 19 November, "Transatlantic securitisation gap revisited: comparing EU and US securitisation architectures", by Germar Knöchlein and Cristina Morar Triandafil. As with all papers in the series, the views are the authors' and not necessarily the ECB's. The paper challenges a common premise of the debate on European capital markets: that the EU's securitisation market is structurally weaker than the American one.

The authors argue that the apparent gap in scale comes largely from how securitisation is defined and measured. Headline US volumes are swollen by large government-sponsored agency mortgage-backed securities programmes, while commonly cited comparisons leave out covered bonds, a long-standing part of asset-backed funding in Europe. Europe, they write, reaches similar outcomes through a mix of covered bonds, traditional securitisation and synthetic significant risk transfer, which lets banks shift credit risk and gain capital relief while keeping loans on their balance sheets. Counted together, asset-backed funding over the past two decades has not been one-sided but has shifted with market conditions and the financial cycle.

To compare economies of different size, the paper introduces an "asset mobilisation ratio", which scales asset-based funding and risk transfer to the size of each economy. On that measure the United States still mobilises more, and a meaningful difference in market scale remains, but the gap has narrowed over time. The authors conclude that the difference reflects alternative institutional models rather than a lower level of development.

ECB paper: the EU-US securitisation gap is smaller once covered bonds count
ECB paper: the EU-US securitisation gap is smaller once covered bonds count — Rate Brief

Why it matters

The authors say the question shapes the debate on how capital markets should support growth, and the case for reviving European securitisation is often argued from the size of the US market. If the gap is partly a matter of definitions, the case for change has to rest on what each instrument does, not on a headline volume comparison.